Special Guest Stars Kristen Schaal as The Guide Co Starring Parisa Fakhri as Marwa Liam McKenna as Child Colin #3 Violet Tinnirello as Child Colin #2 Anoop Desai as Djinn Michael Hough as Hobgoblin Nicolas Grimes as Menacing Vampire Alex Jade as Valkyrie 2 Laura Ramoso as Valkyrie i Susan Applewhaite as Crone Cage Vendor Shel Goldstein as Hag Vampire Nick Corirossi as Ring Master Abbas Wahab as Subway Performer Richard Willis as Warlock Steve Bidwell as Older Gentleman Peggy Calvert as Elderly Lady Familiar Kurtys Kidd as Demon Joel Koshy as Young Vampire