Special Guest Stars Gary Cole as Kurt McVeigh Alan Cumming as Eli Gold Guest Stars Brenda Braxton as Madeline Gilford Mike Pniewski as Frank Landau Gregory Connors as Bearded Man Adeola Role as Delia Gish Anastasia Barzee as Dr. Alyssa Schuman Erich Bergen as Steven Sheen Dax Rey as Troy Dawes Kenneth Tigar as Judge James Chase Neal Huff as Wesley Kirkpatrick Fergie L. Philippe as Hamilton Swing #1 Patrice Johnson as Natalee Steven Huynh as Hamilton Swing #4 David Holbert as Hamilton Swing #3 Jesse Nager as Hamilton Swing #2 Madison Kline as Ri'Chard's Child Arianna Thomas as Studying Girl Raquel Chavez as Jennifer Burns Ashley Blanchet as Rosario Jim Ballard as Dr. Dustin Gore Denny Dale Bess as Police Detective