Guest Stars Austin Stowell as Pete Welsh Joe Chrest as Bishop Matthew Paulse Patrick Fischler as Garth Pincock Bree Elrod as Jennifer Ferguson Keilah Davies as Young Caroline Hansen Co Starring Mila Harris as Young Karen Broberg Elle Lisic as Young Susan Broberg Wyatt Parker as Jasper Berchtold Tyler Wojton as Joel Berchtold Lauren Revard as Brenda Young Steven Sean Garland as Agent Richard McDaniel Richard Hempton as Howard Armstrong Jennifer Schottstaedt as Nurse Atwood Paul Ryden as Dr. Rush Becca Potter as Mrs. Jorgensen Tony Scott as Clerk