Guest Stars Austin Stowell as Pete Welsh Meg Steedle as Sherry Philip Ettinger as Joe Berchtold Bonita Friedericy as Sister Ramona Bruce McKinnon as Roger Flynn Nyaling Marenah as Sister Margaret Ella Jay Basco as Sofia Co Starring Norah Murphy as Older Susan Broberg Maggie Sonnier as Older Karen Broberg Kate Adams as Eileen Ava Leigh as Carly Callie Johnson as Cop #4 Cara Reid as Waitress Vince Pisani as Phone Tech Antoine Williams as Officer Jensen Carl Kennedy as Cop #3 Taron Germany as Cop #1 Veanna Black as Cop #2 Clayton Landey as Detective George Shail