Guest Stars Yani Alekansandrov as Humphrey's Body Bridget Christie as Annie John Macmillan as Scott Bruce MacKinnon as Isaac - Puritan Man Jason Thorpe as Samuel - Puritan Man William Andrews as Josiah - Annie's Husband David Reed as Restoration Man Alistair Green as Owen Giulia Innocenti as Restoration Woman Declan Baxter as Ambrose Melissa Saint as Laetitia