Guest Stars Andrew Rannells voices Matthew MacDell Chloe Fineman voices Leah Birch Jon Daly voices Judd Birch Thandiwe Newton voices Mona Mark Duplass voices Val Bilzerian Heather Lawless voices Jenna Bilzerian Paul Scheer voices Kurt Bilzerian Brian Tyree Henry voices Elijah Rosa Salazar voices Ms. Benitez Chris O'Dowd voices Flanny O'Lympic Gil Ozeri voices Additional Voices Peter Capaldi voices Seamus McGregor Kristen Schaal voices Bernie Sanders Brandon Kyle Goodman voices Youth Group Teacher Georgie Kidder voices Diane Lane Emily Altman voices Jerk Shack Waitress Devon Walker voices Additional Voices