Guest Stars Shannon Kane as Shanelle Tucker Pauletta Washington as Mama Lu Victor Rasuk as Mike Ortiz Sean Patrick Thomas as Brayden Mitchell Christopher Cassarino as Rich Reed Tiffany Yvonne Cox as Autumn Owens Eugene Byrd as CJ Cooke Nefetari Spencer as Sally Braswell Aries Sanders as Fallon Stephens Brooke Lyons as Sarah Miller Paul Fox as Theo James Debbie Fan as Judge Green Toby Onwumere as Will Perri Camper as Kaleesha Moore Christopher Mychael Watson as Jamarion "JT" Tucker Christian Keyes as Ryan Moore Erin Croom as Morgan Stephens Co Starring Summer Spiro as Kate Jasmine Akakpo as Kanika Paul Norwood as Terry Binder Carla Mansour as Reporter Two Kamran R. Khan as Juror Consultant Jim Rachel Paulson as Waitress Lawrence J. Lacey as Potential Juror 8 Ella James as Potential Juror 3 Easton von der Lieth as Langston Miller Sunday Curry as Lana Miller Lisa Saum as Britney Dylan Stretchbery as Reporter One Erwin R. Jones as Bystander