Guest Stars Richard Gant as Raymond Hanna Alicia Coppola as FBI Senior Special Agent Lisa Rand Tobias Jelinek as Robert "Bobby" Griffin Rob Nagle as Albert Barrington Teya Patt as Cindy Ferguson Derrick A. King as Michael Jeffries J.D. Cullum as FBI Forensic Psychologist Mark Collins Antony Del Rio as Alexander Hughes Adrian Elizondo as Philip Guerrero Co Starring Matt Kelly as Justin Tucker / Clown