Guest Stars Robert Patrick as Sheriff McDowell Marley Shelton as Emma Dutton Sebastian Roché as Father Renaud Jennifer Ehle as Sister Mary Leenah Robinson as Baapuxti Tim DeKay as Bob Strafford James Badge Dale as John Dutton Sr. Kerry O'Malley as Sister Alice Nick Boraine as Richard Holland Alexandra Grossi as Catherine Walsh Co Starring Caleb Martin as Dennis Kondwani Phiri as Linda Jeff Leaf as Charles Brewster Tyler Gaisford as Horace Grant Tony Noto as Man (Sheeper) Bradley Fisher as Clive Hoburn Raymond Watanga as Kagiso Scott Buechler as Sheep Herder (Fence Cut) Clyde Berning as Richard Walsh Erin Coker as Edna Paul Chirico as Cowboy (Town Hall) Hunter Goligoski as Soldier Arthur Anderson as Bartender Phillip Dikotla as Bellman