Guest Stars Josh Braaten as Director Cas Courtney Taylor as Mason Shaylee Mansfield as Ollie Nicoletti Timothy V. Murphy as Patrick Maguire Essence Atkins as Shelby Bridget Regan as Tina Doug Savant as Pastor Evan Earle III Co Starring Efka Kvaraciejus as Seamus Michael Bow as Kevin Steve Olson as Business Exec Jamie VanDyke as Mrs. Ferrari Cheryl Bricker as Donor Wife Fizaa Dosani as Stacy Padman Paul Urcioli as Mystery Man Jonathon Buckley as Agent Johnson Marshall Fox as Bartender Rick Tom McComas as Ferrari Guy Uncredited Steven Stone as Private Jet Pilot