Guest Stars Dave Wasson voices Henchman Luke Millington-Drake voices Devil Dave Wasson voices Telephone Andrew Morgado voices Stickler Rick Zieff voices Croaks Chris Wylde voices Ribby Fred Tatasciore voices Santa Grey DeLisle Griffin voices Elves April Winchell voices Hoagie Mom April Winchell voices Kindly Old Woman Andrew Morgado voices Demon Andrew Morgado voices Stickler-Elf Luke Millington-Drake voices Children Cosmo Segurson voices Demon Cosmo Segurson voices Elves Dave Wasson voices Elves Dave Wasson voices Sammy Sandwich