Guest Stars Aisha Tyler as Dr. Tara Elisabeth Lewis Benito Martinez as Chief Raul Montoya Emily Rios as Tammy May Vasquez Grainger Hines as Brooks Tanner Jackson Robert Scott as Cole Vasquez Stephen Monroe Taylor as Lester Turner Jesse Luken as William Duke Mason Monica Garcia as Ruth Vasquez Danube R. Hermosillo as Renee Acosta Rebekah Salgado as Nadine Acosta Emanuel Loarca as Father Robert Garcia as Clerk O.C. Rodriguez as Jose Rivera Andrew Matarazzo as Eddie Butler Alaska Reid as Eva Montoya Tony Colitti as Dr. Reuben Jenkins Doug Cox as Randall McAdams Blake Heron as Benjamin Wade Mauricio Mendoza as Oscar Acosta