Guest Stars Elisha Cuthbert as Maxine Denver Elizabeth Bogush as Greta Wilkes Jadin Gould as Lucy Donovan Scott Michael Campbell as William Hollander Karis Campbell as Karen Summers Co Starring Jake Borelli as High School Guy Joey Luthman as Matthew Clarke Pilar Holland as Denise Brady Hender as Troy Pearl Laura Ann Kesling as Stephanie Summers / Jane Doe Dawn Greenidge as Social Worker Jessica Lancaster as Lisa Price Whitney Blair as High School Girl Kevin Vyce as Vendor