Guest Stars J.B. Smoove as Luke Wanda Sykes as Shirley Chisholm Kym Whitley as Florynce Kennedy Colton Dunn as Conrad Chisholm Jay Ellis as Jesus Christ Richard Kind as Peter Nick Kroll as Judas Zazie Beetz as Mary Magdalene Ronny Chieng as Kublai Khan Ike Barinholtz as Mark Rob Riggle as Roman Soldier D'Arcy Carden as Turkish Ambassador Poppy Liu as Ehri Kimiko Glenn as Chabi Andy Cohen as Andy Khan Michaela Watkins as Israeli Ambassador Casey Wilson as Gloria Steinem Mary Holland as Typhoid Mary Jason Mantzoukas as Greek Ambassador Christos Andy Daly as Norwegian Ambassador Mena Massoud as Egyptian Ambassador Finesse Mitchell as Reverend Jesse Jackson Mousa Kraish as Palestine Ambassador Amir Carl Tart as Lazarus Crystal Kung Minkoff as Crystal Co Starring Edgar Blackmon as Apostle Owen Burke as Red Sox Fan Brian Huskey as Watergate Burglar Atsuko Okatsuka as Nambui Sandi McCree as Watergate Receptionist Fran Gillespie as Roman Woman Caleb Jeon as Travis Donisha Walker as Server Scout Tayui-Lepore as Kayla Sophia Tayui-Lepore as Kaylah CJ Uy as Travis