Guest Stars Mark Sheppard as Hagan Timothy Granaderos as Shane Davidson Valerie Cruz as Teresa Davidson Jonathan Medina as Otis Clay Dylan Silver as Stella Rawlins Co Starring Vincent E. McDaniel as Blacksmith Blake Webb as Texas Ranger Jodi Lynn Thomas as Eliza Teddy Blum as Kid Hoyt Rawlins Jessica Mastrippolito as Beth Ramiro Montanez as Attendant 1 Brendan Healy as Sam Steven Glenn as Drunk Cowboy Everette Scott Ortiz as Attendant 2 Kirby Rhoades as Stage Coach Driver Uncredited Jared Padalecki as Man With No Name