Guest Stars Kennedy McMann as Joni DeGroot Michael Weston as Bob Patton Karen Robinson as Judge J. Kileen Felicity Huffman as Janet Stewart Jordan Belfi as Ross Daniel Bacon as Dr. Rutenberg Bethlehem Million as Abbie Co Starring Avery Grant as Young Abbie Hazel Bartlett-Sias as Young Joni Maria Meadows as Joni's Mother Janene Rose as Emily Patton Femi Sobaki as Bailiff Robin Horn as Mutton Chop Juror