Guest Stars Colton Gobbo as Mike Jr. Nora McLellan as Principal Sister Rose Daisy Harris as Tina Teigan Follett as Middle Fox Petrina Bromley as Sister Margaret Lawrence Barry as Mr. Chafe Noah Hepditch as Gary Eugene Sampang as Mr. Perez Katie A. Sullivan as Choir Nun #1 Jennifer Nakashima as Choir Nun #2 Michelle Chippett as Choir Nun #3 Ann Connolly as Choir Nun #4 Andrea Lane Gardner as Choir Nun #5 Julia Halfyard as Choir Mom #1 Angela Warren as Choir Mom #2 Abra Whitney as Choir Mom #3