Guest Stars Roxana Brusso as Andrea Reyes Ashley Spillers as Lila Geralds Jamison Webb as Mitch Geralds John Clarence Stewart as Joe Keon Alexander as Fauza Niousha Noor as Fara Karim Paul Karmiryan as Zain Co Starring David Grant Wright as Reverend Tom Briana Lane as Pastor Nicole Mark Sipka as Ed Joseph Whipp as Bill Harvey J. Alperin as Rabbi Finkel Neil Holland as Chip Islam Meligi as Omar Sia Zami as Hassan Maureen Driscoll as Amethyst