Guest Stars Micah Gordon as courtship. Eli Reuben Hirsch as courtship. Daniel Maslany as Public Defender Eli Demille Christopher Russell as Josh Donovan Julia Goldani Telles as Alice Baylor Matthew Edison as ADA Simon Stacher Matthew James Thomas as Tom Braddick Maya Misaljevic as Mia Anne Bedian as Rita Khalil Phi Huynh as Bailiff #3 Alex Hrgetic as Ryan Michala Brasseur as Hot Girlfriend Stacy Smith as Judge Chapman Aaron Walpole as Bailiff #2 Ellie Ellwand as Becky Blaise Crocker as Shawna Ellen Oatmeyer as Test Proctor Liam Kinahan as Pete Adam Bakri as Samir Khalil Teq Zwarych as Bailiff #1 Victor Ertmanis as Mr. Branson Frank Martinez Nodarse as Drummer Adam Waxman as Jury Foreman