Guest Stars Anders Holm as JJ Stephanie D'Abruzzo as Tina Teeth Dave Goelz as Jimmy Shoe David Bizzaro as Gerald Teeth Sr. Kristen Schaal as Jenny Henderson Arden Myrin as Annie Waits Nico Santos as Jackson Cannery Dave Goelz as Waldorf Peter Linz as Statler Co Starring Alice Dinnean as Supporting Muppet Performer Bradley Freeman Jr. as Supporting Muppet Performer Bruce Lanoil as Supporting Muppet Performer Donna Kimball as Supporting Muppet Performer Michelan Sisti as Supporting Muppet Performer Terrell Lee as Security Guard Drew Massey as Supporting Muppet Performer