Guest Stars Harlan Drum as CeCe Matney Ella Grace Helton as Katie Townsend Tracey Bonner as Pastor June Wilkes Brittany L. Smith as Peggy Martin Caroline Lagerfelt as Paula Vreeland Shawn Passwaters as Dr. Howie Young Chase Anderson as Jeremy Reynolds Elena House as Lily Vickie Eng as Grace Wharton Gabriella Garcia as Sophie Frazier Alpha Trivette as Neville Wharton Lana Jean Turner as Willow Tommi Rose as Olivia Harris Jermaine Rivers as Charles Perkins Alexa Havins Bruening as Vicky Brock D. Vickers as Drew Curtis Jones as Preacher Mosby Hannah Lowther as Rabbi Berton