Guest Stars Gillian Jacobs as Tiffany Jerimovich Sarah Ramos as Jessica Olivia Colman as Chef Terry Adam Shapiro as Ever CDC Andrew Lopez as Garrett Co Starring Rene Gube as Ever GM Sarah Charipar as Ever Guest Carley Cornelius as Ever Diner Paulina Pahl as Ever Server Minwoo Kong as Ever Commis Joey Dismore as Tim Claire Connelly as Jill Noah Schenker as Pequod's Employee Andrew Muwonge as Guest Friend #1 Ani Martirosyan as Guest Friend #2