Special Guest Stars Mike O'Malley as Charlie Gully CM Punk as Ricky Rabies Guest Stars Marcia DeBonis as Debbie Alice Barrett Mitchell as Carol David James Elliott as Tom "King" Spade Brian Scannell as Paul Gully Josh Segarra as Brooks Rizzo Aaron O'Connell as Young Tom Spade Carolyn Holding as Young Carol Judd Lormand as Joe Canniff Anna Eilinsfeld as Young Willie Anthony Coons as Young Wild Bill Co Starring Scott Hunter as The Dad Luke Hawx as The Hole Hudson Hughes as Five-Year-OId Jack Jaime Andrews as Director Satya Nikhil Polisetti as Sam Ira Carmichael as Terry Andrews Anthony Michael Lopez as Wesley Kimberly Medina Courts as Delores Kate Wilson as Sally