Special Guest Stars Mike O'Malley as Charlie Gully Guest Stars Marcia DeBonis as Debbie Joel Murray as Eddie Earl Eliza Coyle as Annie Earl Duke Davis Roberts as Big Jim Kitchen Larry Clarke as Ted Day Brian Scannell as Paul Gully Josh Segarra as Brooks Rizzo Fiona O'Malley as Lucy Gully Emmy Raver-Lampman as Jennifer Lussier Co Starring Scott Hunter as The Dad Luke Hawx as The Hole Andrew Henault as Kevin Margaret Morris as Robin Day DJ Walton as Lucifer 78 Elena House as Caitlyn Rick Andosca as Kenneth Grace Junot as Dr. Dominic Jemarion Jones as Home Director