Guest Stars Ward Horton as Charles Fane Nathan Lane as Ward McAllister Audra McDonald as Dorothy Scott Claybourne Elder as John Adams Ashlie Atkinson as Mamie Fish Amy Forsyth as Caroline 'Carrie' Astor David Furr as Dashiell Montgomery Robert Sean Leonard as Reverend Matthew Forte Matilda Lawler as Frances Montgomery Jeremy Shamos as Mr. Gilbert Rebecca Haden as Flora McNeil Christopher Denham as Robert McNeil Jordan Mahome as Samuel Spring Co Starring Tony Carlin as Tritton Peter Bradbury as Jay Gould Sarah Joy Miller as Christina Nilsson Juliet Perrell as Kitchen Maid LaTonya Borsay as Grandmother Spring Gregory Dann as Barman Don Clark Williams as Pastor