Guest Stars Daniel Gillies as Elijah Mikaelson David Anders as John Gilbert Arielle Kebbel as Lexi Branson Bryton James as Luka Martin Randy J. Goodwin as Jonas Martin Dawn Olivieri as Andie Star Co Starring Joe Knezevich as Jonathan Gilbert Daniel Thomas May as Thomas Fell Kelly Finley as Honoria Fell Valee Gallant as Girl #1 Carissa Capobianco as Girl #2