Guest Stars Jonathan Whitesell as Thomas Miller Payne Merasty as Young Tye Spears Sierra Rose McRae as Young Perseverance Spears Ethan Evans as Preteen Johnnie Spears Summer Testawich as Young Aline Spears Tahmoh Penikett as Major Stevens John Tench as Trueman Quinn Kindall Charters as Charlie Tomkins Tim Beckmann as Dr. Douglas Shannon Baker as Sally Whallach Benjamin Jacobson as Jewish Boy Brett Harris as Dr. Dune Jeff Gladstone as Roger Wells Gerald Auger as Chief Wandering Spirit Jonathon Connelly as Josh Sanders Guy Castonguay as Bishop Willis Alexey Gammer as Father John Cameron Fraser Monroe as Young Dr. Tim Whallach Ruth Peters as Askuwheteau's Mother Conner Alook-Oar as Askuwheteau Daryll Laboucan as Askuwheteau's Father