Guest Stars Blair Redford as Will Ravi Patel as Dr. Henry Sydney Morton as Allie Sean Meehan as Ed James Naughton as Gay Talese Jason Ralph as Aaron Knodel Brían F. O'Byrne as Mark Wilkin Heather Goldenhersh as Arlene Wilkin Roger Wayne as Random Guy Co Starring Michael J. Burg as Father Hines Ziva Jane as Sophie Ford Reilly Walters as Teenage Aidan Madison Ferris as Betty Lou Augie Murphy as Teenage Lina Jess Gabor as Billie Dunton Salma Shaw as Jillian Camila Canó-Flaviá as Jordan McKale Jude Bingham as Girl 1 Logan Crawford as Newscaster Robby W. Johnson as Male Employee Sabrina Aziz as Female Server Emmy Harrington as Diana Caroline Kinsolving as Spin Instructor Maia Scalia as Lydia John Beckwith as Kurt Matthew Marcus as Joe Paul Schwensen as Luke Kyle Moore as Manager Anya Stevens as Girl 2 Ella Cardelfe as Girl 3