Guest Stars Ravi Patel as Dr. Henry Sean Meehan as Ed Austin Stowell as Aidan Henny Russell as Rosemary Co Starring Michael J. Burg as Father Hines Reilly Walters as Teenage Aidan Madison Ferris as Betty Lou Augie Murphy as Teenage Lina Caitlin Mehner as Lizzie Elizabeth Morton as Missy Zuzanna Szadkowski as Margaret Finn Brown as Ryan Angela Polite as Mrs. Matthews Caroline Neff as Randy Laura Gourdine as Sheryl Blair Sams as Maxine Amanda Lea Mason as Sara-Beth Maddie Robert as Jennifer Patricia Hurley as Delia Alex Nordin as Waiter Cate Bottiglione as Francine Christopher Bailey as Dustin Dan Thompson as Jeff Jen Ponton as Barbara Katie Lee Hill as Donna Helen Coxe as Cathy Ava Sofía Mattox as Ava Isabel Ellison as Another Woman Erica Bradshaw as Karen