Guest Stars Alicia Coppola as Joy Deaver Rachel Miner as Mary Costello Josh Hopkins as Michael Stires Ross McCall as Scott Costello Leonard Roberts as DA Andrew Levitt Matt Ross as Neil Meredith Kate McNeil as Audrey Schilling Lou Richards as Dr. Barragan Co Starring Keith Sellon-Wright as Brian Schilling Uncredited Patti Yasutake as Judge Lang