Special Guest Stars Kaitlin Olson as DJ Vance J. Smith-Cameron as Kathy Vance Christina Hendricks as Gay Republican Guest Stars Christopher McDonald as Marty Ghilain Paul Felder as Aidan Luke Cook as Jack Danby Tony Goldwyn as Bob Lipka Co Starring Jon Curry as Morgan Henry Amy Heidt as Alice Harry Murphy as Carter Walsh Brittney Guzman as Dancing Elf 3 Kevin Thompson as Lee Jim Hanna as Affiliate 3 Matthew Glen Johnson as Simon Tonya Reneé Banks as Dancing Elf 5 David Guzmán as Dancing Elf 2 Landis Aponte as William Chris Patrickson as Gabriel Richard Bon Bon Centeno as Bellman Ted Chun as Mitch Lina Godouse as Dancing Elf 1 Susan Lenore Gray as Dancing Elf 8 Jeremy Hallam as Dancing Elf 7 Kyle Pacek as Dancing Elf 6 Jonathan M. Kim as Dancing Elf 4