Guest Stars Joel David Moore as Colin Fisher Marisa Coughlan as Agent Payton Perotta Tara Buck as Valerie Daniels Eric Nenninger as Peter Kroon Betsy Rue as Shiny Kopinsky Oliver Muirhead as Badgley Mormont Charles Rahi Chun as Bruce Kim Charlie Stewart as Trev the Mage Poetri as Chip Derf Austin Rogers as Warrior Co Starring David Greenman as FBI Forensic Tech Marcus Geier Josh Sussman as Afro Geek Jon Collins as Geek On-Looker Carlon Jeffery as Ezra the Elf