Guest Stars Diana Bang as Helen Gale Emily Tennant as Lucy Lapp Shaun Smyth as Deacon Amos Miller Beatrice Zeilinger as Miriam Miller Luke Humphrey as Ezekiel "Zeke" Lapp Co Starring Steph Song as Tilda Harvey Rose Marel as Leah Ali Yassine as Security Guard Cooper Bews as Jedidiah "Jed" Lapp