Special Guest Stars Ryan O'Neal as Max Keenan Zooey Deschanel as Margaret Whitesell Guest Stars Carla Gallo as Daisy Wick Tiffany Hines as Michelle Welton Melinda Page Hamilton as Georgia Hartmeyer Wendy Phillips as Abby Chevaleer Dorian Missick as Owen Thiel Matt McTighe as Santa Jack Kehler as Malaki Wallace J.J. Boone as Teller