Guest Stars Jason Mantzoukas as Rafi Nadine Velazquez as Sofia Lizzy Caplan as Rebecca Ruxin Aziz Ansari as Dr. Henry Rocha Co Starring Adam Karchmer as Baby Geoffrey Antonio Sabàto Jr. as Father Zaragosa Adam Jackson as Choir Singer #5 Marianne Chambers as Nurse Bobette Jamison-Harrison as Choir Singer #1 Alfie Silas as Choir Singer #2 Alexandra Brown as Choir Singer #3 Oren Waters as Choir Singer #4 Lamont Vanhook as Choir Singer #6