Guest Stars Mike Faiola as Kevin Hamilton Barret Swatek as Ally Saxton Wesam Keesh as Kyle Cohen Evan Crooks as Theo Abbott Monty Geer as Cole Higgins Evan Williams as Luke Kofi Siriboe as Tyler Shane Harper as Austin Welch Amanda Foreman as Barbara McKibben Matt Corboy as Jim McKibben Co Starring Jenna Lamia as Lesley Miller Juette Raphael as Recruiter