Guest Stars Peter MacKenzie as Rev. Peter Mayfair Mary Page Keller as Emily Chase Co Starring Kaitlyn Black as Annabeth Nass Ross Philips as Tom Long Mallory Moye as Wanda Brandi Burkhardt as Crickett Watts Claudia Lee as Magnolia Breeland John Eric Bentley as Sheriff Bill Armelia McQueen as Shula Whitaker Deborah S. Craig as Shelley Ng Esther Scott as Delma Warner Carla Renata as Susie Collins Kim Robillard as Sal Nutter Dawn Didawick as Old Lady #1 Ilene Graff as Clora Tucker Drew Koles as Frederick Dean Misty Monroe as Saleswoman