Guest Stars Kaitlyn Black as Annabeth Nass Steven M. Porter as Frank Moth Charlie Robinson as Sergeant Jeffries Peter MacKenzie as Rev. Peter Mayfair Amy Ferguson as Lily Anne Lonergan Travis Van Winkle as Jonah Breeland Bonita Friedericy as Lady on Airplane Tom Gossin as Themselves Mike Gossin as Themselves Rachel Reinert as Herself Co Starring Ross Philips as Tom Long Reginald VelJohnson as Dash Dewitt Mallory Moye as Wanda Brandi Burkhardt as Crickett Watts Claudia Lee as Magnolia Breeland Matt Lowe as Meatball Nicolette Robinson as Tara Lynn Ursula Burton as Gloria Gainey Ewan Chung as Flight Attendant Amrapali Ambegaokar as Rachel Katya Lidsky as Rental Car Agent Andrew McGinnis as Doug