Guest Stars Carolyn Hennesy as Barbara Coman David Clayton Rogers as Matt Tyler Steelman as Robbie Chris Zylka as BJ Austyn Wells as Woman Gregory Hinton as Bouncer Thomas Crawford as Principal Stacy Barnhisel as Robbie's Mom Ryan Biegel as Shirtless Guy Jonathan McDaniel as Ryan Kevin Gould as Young Man Lou Mulford as Ms. Pritchett Samantha Cope as Girl Peter Looney as Man