Guest Stars Sharif Atkins as FBI Agent Clinton Jones James Rebhorn as Reese Hughes Noah Emmerich as Garrett Fowler Erik Palladino as Mr. Herrera Kate Hodge as Judge Michelle Clark Co Starring Piper Kenny as OPR agent Patch Darragh as David Sullivan Kate Gilligan as Clerk Tony Cucci as Ray the courier Haley Scott as Allison Jim Lavin as Agent Price