Guest Stars Neil Jackson as Abraham Van Brunt Matt Barr as Nick Hawley Caroline Ford as Lilith Co Starring Jeremy Owens as Headless Horseman Kevin Patrick Murphy as Bartender Sophia Grillo as Bachelorette Greg Perrow as Duncan Elena Sanchez as Lilith Connor McCabe as Robbie Raven Angeline Whisnant as Kalinda Colin Owens as Eric Jenna Bryant as Melissa Mary Russell as Becky Brett Kelley as Bachelor