Guest Stars Idara Victor as Nina Holiday Enver Gjokaj as Jack Armstrong Jamie Bamber as Paul Wescourt Karis Campbell as Carol Wescourt Meagan Holder as Mallory Kyla Kenedy as Charlotte John Bobek as Jimmy McGuinness Maitlyn Pezzo as Allie Armstrong Co Starring Stephanie Pearson as Danielle Mitchell Terrence Edwards as Sheriff's Deputy Baylee O'Hara as Amy