Guest Stars Scott Wolf as Donald 'Donnie' Ryan David Paymer as Rueben Bauer Nancy Youngblut as Judge Leslie Markway Alexis Cruz as Joseph Garcia Brian Thompson as Vernon Hill Evan Jones as Billy Flynn Evan Helmuth as Charlie Kendricks Gordon Clapp as Alan Kendricks Co Starring Dana Daurey as Sara Mark Berry as Jury Foreman Ingo Neuhaus as Prison Guard Brooke Stone as Neighbor David S. Jung as Artist Ray Chang as Medical Examiner Amy E. Kiser as Beautiful Woman