Guest Stars Justin Hartley as Reggie Starr Hilarie Burton Morgan as Kay Cappuccio Nana Visitor as Dr. Patty Barker Scott Lowell as David Hernand Tommy Savas as Marcus Hiatt Charles Carpenter as Reporter Ed F. Martin as Francisco Pilar Robin Sachs as Announcer Andre Ing as Photographer Jim Abele as Adam Greene Dale Waddington Horowitz as Kelly Gunther Tiffany Lowery as Phoebe Diane Modafferi as Uniform Cop