Guest Stars Eric Balfour as Gabe Dimas Jennifer Griffin as Crying Sicilian Daughter Richard Jenkins as Nathaniel Fisher Dina Spybey-Waters as Tracy Montrose Blair Gary Hershberger as Matthew Gilardi Tim Maculan as Priest Sharon Madden as Woman Mourner Hayden Tank as Young Nate Maximillian Kesmodel as Young David Annabelle Gutman as A friend Audrey Gelfund as Crying Sicilian Mother Dennis J. Lau as Morgue Attendant Dennis Anderson as Market Clerk Dennis Lau as Morgue Attendent Harper Roisman as Elderly Man