Special Guest Stars Ryan Tedder as Himself Guest Stars Leslie Odom Jr. as Sam Strickland Michael Cristofer as Jerry Rand Emory Cohen as Leo Houston Thorsten Kaye as Nick Felder Will Chase as Michael Swift Neal Bledsoe as John Goodwin Charlie Semine as Paul Denby Grace Gummer as Katie Rand Co Starring Savannah Wise as Jessica Wesley Taylor as Bobby Jenny Laroche as Sue Joshua Bergasse as Josh Phillip Spaeth as Dennis Derek Ferguson as Dancer Joe Aaron Reid as Dancer Rickey Tripp as Dancer Marcus Bellamy as Dancer Christopher King as Dancer Tala Ashe as R.J. Quigley Condola Rashad as Cynthia "Cyn" Moran Michelle Federer as Monica Swift Blake Johnson as Artie Swift Zach Shaffer as Andrew David Lipman as Judge Davenport Vanessa A. Jones as Co-Worker T.J. Kenneally as McMannus Seth Stewart as Dancer