Guest Stars Michael Cristofer as Jerry Rand Brian d'Arcy James as Frank Houston Daphne Rubin-Vega as Agnes Mara Davi as Daisy Parker Luke Macfarlane as Patrick Dillon Christine Ebersole as Herself Cheyenne Jackson as Himself Mary Testa as Outer Critics Circle Hostess Co Starring Savannah Wise as Jessica Wesley Taylor as Bobby Alexandra Hulme as Dancer Reed Kelly as Dancer Montego Glover as Marissa Shaun Licata as Cathie Michael Riedel as Himself Alice Lee as Bombshell Fan 1 Drew Gehling as Bartender Bryan Langlitz as Correctional Officer Dee Hoty as Director Natalie Peyser as Bombshell Fan 2 Happy Anderson as Doorman Christine Toy Johnson as Dr. Holland Mike DiSalvo as Theatergoer Taivon McKinney as Assistant Michael Musto as Himself