Guest Stars Lauren Diewold as Emily Sim Glenn Morshower as Aaron Starkey Emily Perkins as Dara Kernof / Paula Koklos / Roberta Dyer JP Finn as Confessional Priest Jody Racicot as Father Gregory Co Starring Arnie Walters as Father McCue Eric Keenleyside as Lance Kernof Patti Allan as Mrs. Kernof Lorraine Landry as Pathologist Vicki Belon Tracy Elofson as Four-Faced Man