Special Guest Stars Dylan Walsh as Carl Feeney Guest Stars Stephanie Niznik as Nina Feeney Mike Erwin as Colin Hart Nancy Everhard as Sharon Hart Ryan Armstrong as Sam Feeney Christopher Neiman as Coach Lewis Co Starring Micaela Nelligan as Martha Valerie Welcker as Kayla Katie Millar as Page Ian Vogt as Matthew Lansing Jeff Olson as Davenport David Downs as Principal Ackerman Katharine Clark Reilly as Ms. Marvin Marissa Porritt as Girl #2 Amy Beaudine as The Dance Girl Dan Merket as The Fan Liz Edmiston as Miss Rodionoff