Special Guest Stars Ray Romano as Nicky Kohlbrenner Guest Stars Beau Wirick as Sean Donahue Jen Ray as Nancy Donahue Blaine Saunders as Carly Sean O'Bryan as Ron Donahue Amy Crofoot as Jill Hobert Trevor Glen Campbell as Hot Dog Boy Co Starring Laura Ann Kesling as Dotty Donahue Sam Schuder as Shelly Donahue Jill Tracy as Jill Hobert Liz Montgomery as Lisa the Librarian Kathryn Collins as Cute Girl no. 1 Ashley Hawkins as Cute Girl no. 2